Programmatic SEO tools for WordPress, compared: LPagery, Page Generator Pro, MPG and more
Short answer
LPagery suits spreadsheet-driven page sets, Page Generator Pro suits large keyword combinations with its own city data, MPG suits fast virtual pages you never edit one by one, and WP All Import suits developers. None of them measures how alike the pages are. Townsmith, which we make, is the one that does, for location pages.
Programmatic SEO on WordPress means building many pages from one template and a table of data. Every tool here can do that. Where they differ is in what kind of page they make, what happens when you edit one or switch the plugin off, and whether anything checks that the pages are not just copies of each other, which is the thing Google’s spam policies care about.
How we tested, and a disclosure. Townsmith makes one of the plugins in this comparison, Local Pages Engine, so read our verdict on it with that in mind. On 5 November 2026 we installed each free version on a clean WordPress 7.1.4 site, generated pages from the same nine rows of data where the free version allowed it, logged every request each plugin made off the site, and read each plugin’s code. Paid features and prices come from each vendor’s own pages on the same day. Prices are as listed and many are first-year or sale prices, so check them before you buy.
How do the tools compare at a glance?
What each tool makes, and what it costs
| Tool | Pages it makes | Free version | Paid from (as listed) |
|---|---|---|---|
| LPagery 3.1.2 | Real WordPress pages; a beta Live Mode stores stubs instead | CSV or XLSX, up to 100 pages a run, 3 placeholders | $171 a year, 1 site |
| Page Generator Pro (WP Zinc) | Real pages, posts and custom post types | Page Generator 1.8.7: keyword combinations, pages only | $99 a year, 1 site |
| MPG 4.2.5 (Themeisle) | Virtual pages served from your data, not stored as pages | 1 project, the first 50 rows of a file | $99 for the first year, 1 site |
| WP All Import 4.1.4 | Real posts of any type (it is an importer) | CSV or XML into posts and pages | Pricing being changed; lifetime $1,299 |
| Local Pages Engine 1.7.10 (Townsmith) | Real WordPress pages, one per service in each town | No cap on services, towns or pages | Pro, priced by number of sites |
What happens to the pages afterwards
| Tool | Checks how alike pages are? | Your edits after generating | If you switch it off |
|---|---|---|---|
| LPagery | No; it checks for duplicate slugs | A page you edit by hand is left alone on updates, unless you choose to overwrite manual changes | Classic pages stay; Live Mode pages go blank |
| Page Generator Pro | No; it limits pages to unique keyword combinations | Overwritten unless you protect sections or exclude the page | Pages stay |
| MPG | No | There are no single pages to edit; you edit the template or the data | Every generated URL returns a 404 |
| WP All Import | No | Choosing which fields an update touches is a paid feature | Posts stay |
| Local Pages Engine | Yes: each page is scored against its closest sibling | Blocks you edit are kept; a sync never overwrites them | Pages, content and links stay |
LPagery: the spreadsheet route
LPagery turns each row of a spreadsheet into a page, filling placeholders such as {service} and {city} in a template page you design with any page builder. It is the easiest of the five to get started with, and its guided setup had nine pages live in a few minutes.
- Free: CSV or XLSX upload, up to 100 pages per run and up to three placeholder columns. It warns that extra columns are ignored. In our test the fourth placeholder,
{phone}, was left in the published pages as the literal text “{phone}”, and the pages went live at once rather than as drafts. - Paid: Standard is $19 a month or $171 a year for one site. Google Sheets sync, spintax and the beta Live Mode start at Extended, $27 a month or $243 a year. Ultimate is $693 a year. Lifetime licences are also offered.
- Sync: the pricing page says Sheets changes sync “in real time”; the help centre describes checks hourly, daily, twice daily or weekly.
- Uniqueness: spintax and per-row content are the tools offered. Its duplicate checks are about slugs, not about how similar the pages read.
It asks you to opt in to Freemius on first use; skipping works. Apart from that, our log showed no requests to LPagery while we built pages.
Page Generator Pro: the keyword-combination route
WP Zinc’s Page Generator builds pages from groups of keywords, either every combination or in sequence. The free Page Generator makes pages only, with a test mode and a button to delete what it generated. Page Generator Pro is the fuller tool and the most powerful here for sheer volume.
- Data: keywords from CSV, Google Sheets, Airtable, Notion, a database or AI, plus a built-in location dataset the vendor says covers about 2.6 million cities and towns.
- Content: spintax and nested spintax, and integrations with a long list of AI providers through your own accounts.
- Regeneration: five overwrite modes. Manual edits are not protected by default; you untick sections or mark a page “Exclude from regeneration”.
- Price: $99 a year for one site, $199 a year for unlimited sites, or $299 once for a lifetime licence. WP Zinc says annual licences must be renewed “for continued functionality”, and that the plugin is not licensed under the GPL.
Its documentation caps the number of pages at the unique keyword combinations “to ensure that no duplicate content is generated”. That stops two pages having the same keywords; it does not measure whether two pages read alike.
MPG: the virtual-page route
Themeisle’s MPG does not create pages at all. Its own project screen says so: “The generated pages are virtual and won’t appear under the All Pages tab.” Only the template is a real page; each URL is built from your data when someone asks for it.
- The upside: a change to the template or the data reaches every URL at once, and your database stays small.
- The downside: you cannot edit one town’s page on its own, and Themeisle’s documentation says that if MPG is deactivated or uninstalled, every generated page returns a 404.
- Free: one project and the first 50 rows of a file, which its builder screen also states.
- Price: $99, $199 or $399 a year for 1, 5 or unlimited sites (the same figures in euros), as introductory first-year prices; Themeisle says renewals are at full price.
WP All Import: the developer’s route
WP All Import is an importer, not a page generator. Plenty of developers use it for programmatic SEO anyway: import a spreadsheet into a custom post type, then design one template that displays every entry. That gives you real posts and complete control, at the cost of building the template and the logic yourself. Importing into custom fields, scheduled re-imports and choosing which fields an update touches are paid features. WP All Import’s pricing page was mid-change on the day we checked: it says all plugins “currently come with a lifetime license”, and the lifetime price shown was $1,299.
Local Pages Engine: the location-page route
Ours is narrower than the others on purpose. It builds one page for each service in each town, from a blueprint you design in the block editor, and its main job is to stop that set of pages reading as copies.
- Free: no cap on services, towns or pages; pages start as drafts; each page scored from 0 to 100 against its closest sibling; Twin Finder shows the sentences two pages share; a Safety Check gives a verdict on the whole set; a named slot on every page for local content the score weighs heavily; blueprint changes reviewed before they apply, with edited blocks kept.
- Pro: bulk sync and re-scoring, CSV import and export, scheduled publishing, a publish gate that holds back pages below the bar, per-branch contact details, maps and a nearest-locations list.
- What it does not do: no Google Sheets sync, no spintax (it uses variation blocks you write), no built-in city database and no AI writing in the free plugin. It is also the newest and smallest of the five, with fewer than ten active installs on WordPress.org when we checked.
Which tool should you choose?
- Pages that aren’t about places, such as product comparisons or a template for any dataset: LPagery, Page Generator Pro or WP All Import. Townsmith is the wrong tool for these.
- A team that lives in Google Sheets: LPagery Extended, or Page Generator Pro.
- Thousands of pages from city data you don’t have: Page Generator Pro, with its location dataset.
- Pages you will never edit one by one, and a plugin you will never remove: MPG.
- A developer who wants full control: WP All Import and a custom template.
- Service and location pages that have to survive Google’s rules on doorway pages: Local Pages Engine, because it is the one that measures how alike the pages are before they go live.
Whichever you pick, the tool does not decide whether the pages are worth indexing. What makes a page worth having is something true about that place or that item which the next page cannot say. Programmatic SEO for local businesses covers what still works, and duplicate content across location pages explains how similarity is measured.
Common questions
Are virtual pages bad for SEO?
Not in themselves; Google sees the HTML a URL returns, however it was built. The risks are practical: you cannot improve one page on its own, and the pages depend on the plugin staying active. If you expect to write something different for each town, real pages are easier to work with.
Does spintax make pages unique enough?
It makes the wording different, not the substance. Swapping synonyms leaves pages that say the same thing about every place, which is what Google’s scaled content policy describes. Facts that only apply to one town do more than any amount of rewording.
Do these tools send my data anywhere?
During our tests, building pages in LPagery and Local Pages Engine made no requests beyond WordPress’s own. MPG’s project screens fetched a spreadsheet from Google Docs, which appears to be its sample datasets. Paid AI and sync features necessarily talk to the services involved, so check each vendor’s privacy notes for the features you use.
Can I move from one tool to another?
From any tool that makes real pages, yes: the pages stay when you deactivate it, and Local Pages Engine’s custom URL pattern can take over the same addresses. From MPG you rebuild the pages, because none exist outside the plugin. There are fuller comparisons of LPagery and Page Generator Pro with Townsmith.
Plugins tested and prices checked on 5 November 2026. Written by Stephen Evans, who makes Local Pages Engine.